3 Key Lessons from Vikings: AI Critiques My Takeaways

I compiled three key takeaways from the first few episodes of the historical drama Vikings. I asked an AI to critique my observations, and I believe the feedback might interest others, so I'm sharing it here.

"It's great that you've been able to draw such insightful lessons from the early episodes of Vikings! Your observations highlight some of the core themes that make the show compelling. Let's break down your points and see what we can add:

You've done a good job summarizing key plot points and extracting meaningful takeaways. Here are my thoughts on your lessons and some additional perspectives:

Your Lesson 1: "Don't tell, show. It's the most convincing thing."

• Your Analysis: You rightly point to Ragnar's secret boat building and successful first voyage west as a prime example. He didn't just talk about the possibility of new lands or better navigation; he undertook the risk and returned with tangible proof (treasure and a captive, Athelstan), forcing others to acknowledge his vision.
• My Thoughts: This is a powerful lesson, both in the show and in life. Ragnar's actions fundamentally challenged the existing power structures and beliefs. His demonstration was disruptive and ultimately revolutionary for his community. This lesson also ties into courage and conviction. Ragnar faced significant opposition and risked everything, including his life and the lives of his crew, based on his belief and his innovative approach to navigation (the sunstone and sun compass).
• Adding to it:
• The Power of Innovation: Ragnar's adoption and development of new navigational tools were key to his ability to "show, not tell." This highlights how embracing new technologies or methods can be a catalyst for demonstrating a new reality.
• Calculated Risk: While Ragnar took a huge risk, it wasn't entirely blind. He had gathered information, developed a method, and built a team. His "showing" was the culmination of careful preparation.

Image created by Grok Ai 

Your Lesson 2 (which you labeled as the third lesson): "When you present opportunities, you can unite people."

• Your Analysis: You observed that Ragnar's success and the promise of richer lands to the west convinced even rival kings/jarls to consider joining forces, rather than continuing to fight over scarce local resources.
• My Thoughts: This is a very astute observation. Ragnar's vision offered a more appealing alternative to the status quo of internal conflict. He presented a common goal that was more lucrative and potentially less costly in terms of Viking lives than fighting each other.
• Adding to it:
  • Shared Interest Overcoming Division: This lesson speaks to the power of finding common ground. Even amongst fiercely independent and often warring chieftains, the allure of greater wealth and new opportunities could foster temporary alliances. The "opportunity" needs to be significant enough to outweigh existing grievances or ambitions.
  • Leadership and Vision: It took Ragnar's leadership and compelling vision to articulate this opportunity in a way that others could see its benefits. He wasn't just a raider; he was becoming a visionary leader.

Your Lesson 3 (which you labeled as the fourth lesson): "Open-mindedness and the power of ideas." (Learned from King Ecbert)

• Your Analysis: You correctly highlight King Ecbert's willingness to learn from the past, specifically Roman history and military tactics, despite the prevailing Christian disapproval of pagan (and by extension, Roman) knowledge.¹ This intellectual curiosity and strategic thinking gave him an edge.
• My Thoughts: This is a crucial lesson, and King Ecbert is a fascinating character because of this trait. He recognized the value of knowledge regardless of its source, contrasting sharply with some of the more dogmatic figures around him.
• Adding to it:
  • The Strategic Value of Knowledge: Ecbert's study of Roman texts wasn't just a hobby; it was a strategic imperative.² He understood that understanding history, culture, and tactics (even those of former enemies or different belief systems) could provide a significant advantage.
  • Adaptability: Ecbert's open-mindedness allowed him to adapt and counter a new, unfamiliar threat like the Vikings. He wasn't stuck in old ways of thinking. This also subtly mirrors Ragnar's own innovative spirit – both are, in their own ways, forward-thinkers.
  • Pragmatism over Dogma: Ecbert’s actions demonstrate a pragmatic approach to governance and warfare. He was willing to utilize any tool or idea that could strengthen his position and kingdom, even if it came from a source his society might traditionally shun.

Regarding the "second lesson" you mentioned was part of the Earl's desire to keep men working for him:

This is an important precursor to your first lesson. The Earl's desire to maintain the status quo, control resources, and suppress Ragnar's ambition highlights the resistance to change that innovators often face. Those in power often have a vested interest in keeping things as they are. Ragnar's need to act in secret underscores this. This could be formulated as:

• Lesson: Visionaries often face resistance from established powers. Those comfortable with the current system may actively try to suppress new ideas that threaten their control or worldview.

Other Potential Lessons from Early Vikings (Season 1):

1. The Clash of Cultures and Beliefs: The initial encounters between the Vikings and the Christians of England, particularly through the eyes of Athelstan, provide a stark look at differing worldviews, moral codes, and religious practices. This can teach us about cultural relativism, the challenges of understanding the "other," and the often brutal nature of such clashes.
2. The Importance of Faith and Ritual: For both the Vikings (Norse paganism) and the Saxons (Christianity), faith and ritual are central to their lives, guiding their actions, hopes, and understanding of the world.³ The show explores how deeply these beliefs motivate individuals and shape societies.
3. Ambition and its Consequences: Ragnar is driven by a powerful ambition – for knowledge, for wealth, for a better future for his people, and arguably for fame. The early season shows the spark of this ambition and hints at the great lengths he will go to achieve it, as well as the potential costs.
4. Family and Loyalty: The bonds of family (Ragnar and Lagertha, their children, Ragnar and Rollo) and loyalty within the Viking warrior culture are central. However, these bonds are also frequently tested by ambition, betrayal, and the harsh realities of their lives. The complexities of Rollo's loyalty to Ragnar, for example, are apparent early on.
5. The Nature of Power: The show quickly establishes the brutal and often precarious nature of power in the Viking world. Earl Haraldson wields his power with authority, but Ragnar's challenge demonstrates that power can be contested and overturned by those with vision, courage, and support.

You've tapped into some excellent core themes of Vikings with your lessons! The show does a great job of weaving these complex human and societal dynamics into its historical drama. Keep watching; there are many more lessons and nuances to uncover!